In This Report
The Short Answer
Choose Frenchman's Creek for the breadth of the club. It has two courses, a beach club and access to the Intracoastal. Choose Frenchman's Reserve for a newer house in a smaller community.
Price will not separate them. The two clubs sold houses at nearly the same rate per square foot. The Reserve's median is higher only because its houses are larger.
BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.
What Each One Is
Frenchman's Creek holds about six hundred homes on 720 acres. Its members have two courses, a private beach club and a marina connection to the Intracoastal. Most of its houses date from the late 1980s and 1990s, and renovation is constant.
Frenchman's Reserve was built in the 2000s. Its Arnold Palmer course runs through a compact plan of estate houses in a French country style. The typical house is larger and nearly two decades newer than the typical house in the Creek.
The Same Rate per Foot, a Newer House in the Reserve
Houses sold for a median of $814 per square foot in the Creek and $815 in the Reserve. The Creek's figure hides a wide spread. Rebuilt waterfront houses there sell far above original ones.
The Creek's upper tier is moving fastest. Its median price rose by more than a third between the first and second year of this record, and its highest sale reached $11M. A new clubhouse and a wave of rebuilt houses stand behind that.
The Reserve has traded in a tighter band, with a high of $8.2M. Buyers there face fewer surprises about condition, because the houses are closer in age.
BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.
BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.
BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.
The Reserve Sells in Half the Time
The Reserve is the quicker market. Its median sale reached contract in 33 days and closed at 95 percent of the original asking price. In the Creek the median took 65 days and closed at 87 percent.
That gap matters at the negotiating table. The Creek record shows room for a buyer on houses that need work. The Reserve record shows sellers getting close to what they first asked.
BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.
Who Each One Suits
Frenchman's Creek suits the buyer who wants the most complete club in the Gardens, and who values the beach club and the water. It also suits the buyer willing to renovate.
Frenchman's Reserve suits the buyer who wants a newer estate and a quieter, smaller membership. Its houses need less work on the day of closing.
The two clubs have different membership structures. Ask each club for its current terms, or ask us to set out both before a tour.
Bottom Line
Frenchman's Creek and Frenchman's Reserve share a name and little else. The Creek is larger and older, with two courses, a beach club and a rising upper tier. The Reserve is newer and smaller, with larger houses that sell in half the time and closer to their asking prices.
The working rule for the two Frenchman's: the Creek is a club with houses. The Reserve is houses with a club.
Every figure is a BeachesMLS recorded closing at $1,000,000 or above from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. That is 53 sales in Frenchman's Creek and 31 in Frenchman's Reserve. The scope is each club's own gates, as this site's community pages define them. One record is counted per sale, with listings entered twice matched on address and price. Medians are used throughout and print only at three sales or more. Days measure list date to contract. Transfers recorded only by deed are outside this count. Club membership terms come from each club directly and are not published here.
BeachesMLS recorded closings via our licensed feed, pulled November 16, 2026.
Contact 


