Old Palm or Old Marsh?

Buyer Intelligence

Old Palm or Old Marsh?

Nikko Karki
Nikko Karki November 19, 2026
Old Palm Golf Club and Old Marsh Golf Club are a few miles apart in Palm Beach Gardens. Their names are confused as often as their courses are compared. Each is a private club with one course and estate homes around it. Old Palm plays on a Raymond Floyd design. Old Marsh plays on a Pete Dye design set in a marsh preserve. The median house closed at $5.2M in Old Palm over the last two years and $4.6M in Old Marsh.
Old Palm houses
$5.2M
Median of 37 house sales
Old Marsh houses
$4.6M
Median of 20 house sales
Old Palm per sq ft
$1,138
Median house, same window
Old Marsh per sq ft
$975
Median house, same window

The Short Answer

Choose Old Palm for a larger, more active club with a deep resale market. Choose Old Marsh for a smaller membership and a course in a natural setting. Both are built for people who play several times a week.

The price gap is modest. A buyer with five million dollars has real options in either club, and should let the golf decide.

Old Palm and Old Marsh, side by side
Two years of recorded closings, measured the same way
Old Palm
Old Marsh
Median house price
$5.2M
$4.6M
Median house price per square foot
$1,138
$975
Closings at $1M and above
37
20
Median days to contract
54
84
Share of original asking price
92%
90%
Highest recorded sale
$14M
$9M
Median house size
5,233 sq ft
4,540 sq ft
Golf course
Raymond Floyd
Pete Dye
Known for
No tee times
A caddie tradition
Sales at $10M and above
4
0

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

What Each One Is

Old Palm has about three hundred homes and an equity membership. It is known for open play without tee times and for its practice facility. Its largest houses are custom estates.

Old Marsh covers 456 acres of marsh and preserve. The club keeps a caddie tradition, and its course is the reason most members are there. Far fewer houses change hands in a year.

Old Palm Costs More and Builds Larger

Houses sold for a median of $1,138 per square foot at Old Palm and $975 at Old Marsh. The typical Old Palm house was also larger. Houses in the two clubs were built in the same years, so age does not explain the gap.

Old Palm reaches higher. It recorded four sales at ten million dollars and above, with a high of $14M. The highest sale at Old Marsh was $9M.

Neither figure includes membership. Each club sets its own terms and provides them to buyers directly.

Both clubs trade mostly between $3M and $10M
Closings by price range at $1M and above, November 2024 through October 2026

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

The largest sales in each club
The five largest recorded sales in each, two years
← Scroll to see all columns →
PropertyMarketClosedPriceSqFt$ / SqFt
12218 Tillinghast CircleOld PalmMar 31$14M9,805$1,428
11749 Belladonna CourtOld PalmJul 29$13.5M11,510$1,173
12210 Tillinghast CircleOld PalmJul 27$11.5M8,254$1,396
11612 Charisma WayOld PalmFeb 26$10.7M7,467$1,433
11769 Calla Lilly CourtOld PalmMar 13$8.7M7,392$1,177
13001 BrynwoodOld MarshDec 30$9M9,205$978
13321 OakmeadeOld MarshDec 20$7.4M6,500$1,133
12880 Marsh LandingOld MarshSep 26$7M6,397$1,094
13421 Marsh LandingOld MarshFeb 27$6.5M5,705$1,148
13223 Marsh LandingOld MarshApr 25$5.6M4,802$1,166

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

Old Palm Has Been Selling in a Month

Old Palm is the faster market. Its median sale reached contract in 54 days, against 84 at Old Marsh. In the most recent year the Old Palm median fell to about a month.

Old Marsh trades about ten houses a year. Its sellers closed at 90 percent of their original asking prices, a little below Old Palm's 92 percent. Patience there can be worth something to a buyer.

Two years, one at a time
Each market in two twelve-month windows
← Scroll to see all columns →
SegmentClosingsVolumeMedian$ / SqFtDays
Old Palm, Nov 2024 to Oct 202517$98.1M$5.2M$1,07392
Old Palm, Nov 2025 to Oct 202620$125.8M$5.3M$1,17532
Old Marsh, Nov 2024 to Oct 202510$47.9M$4.7M$1,04474
Old Marsh, Nov 2025 to Oct 202610$48.3M$4.4M$93694

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.

Who Each One Suits

Old Palm suits the buyer who wants an estate of real size, a club with more members and events, and confidence about resale.

Old Marsh suits the player who wants a quiet club, a walking round with a caddie and a house that looks onto preserve.

Play both before deciding. The courses are different enough that most golfers have a clear preference after one round each.

Bottom Line

Old Palm and Old Marsh are Palm Beach Gardens' two estate clubs with a single course. Old Palm is larger, costs somewhat more, reaches above ten million dollars and has been selling in about a month. Old Marsh is smaller and quieter, with fewer sales and a little more room on price.

The working rule for the two Olds: similar houses, different golf. Let the round decide.

Every figure is a BeachesMLS recorded closing at $1,000,000 or above from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. That is 37 sales in Old Palm and 20 in Old Marsh. The scope is each club's own gates, as this site's community pages define them. One record is counted per sale, with listings entered twice matched on address and price. Medians are used throughout and print only at three sales or more. Days measure list date to contract. Transfers recorded only by deed are outside this count. Club membership terms come from each club directly and are not published here.

BeachesMLS recorded closings via our licensed feed, pulled November 16, 2026.

Nikko Karki
Written by

Nikko Karki

Nikko Karki has worked in real estate for nearly two decades, beginning on the developer side at Related Group in West Palm Beach, then through private real estate investments and cross-border M&A across the U.S., Europe, and Southeast Asia. He holds an M.Sc. in economics from the Helsinki School of Economics. He built Palm Beach Luxury to make his analysis available to anyone in the market, for free.
About our team →
Frequently Asked Questions
Somewhat. The median house closed at $5.2M at Old Palm over two years, against $4.6M at Old Marsh.
Raymond Floyd designed Old Palm. Pete Dye designed Old Marsh.
Old Palm. It recorded 37 sales at $1M and above in two years, against 20 at Old Marsh.
Palm Beach Luxury

Every article we write is built on the same research we use to advise our clients. If anything here sparked your interest, we'd welcome a conversation.

Start a Conversation