Admirals Cove or Jonathan’s Landing?

Buyer Intelligence

Admirals Cove or Jonathan’s Landing?

Nikko Karki
Nikko Karki November 8, 2026
Admirals Cove and Jonathan's Landing sit a few minutes apart in Jupiter, and on paper they describe the same life. Each has forty five holes of golf, a marina and the Intracoastal running through it. The prices describe two different markets. The median house in Admirals Cove closed at $7.9M over the last two years. In Jonathan's Landing the figure was $1.9M. This comparison sets out what the difference buys.
Admirals Cove houses
$7.9M
Median of 55 house sales
Jonathan's Landing houses
$1.9M
Median of 51 house sales
Admirals Cove per sq ft
$1,543
Median house, same window
Jonathan's Landing per sq ft
$731
Median house, same window

The Short Answer

Admirals Cove is the larger commitment and the larger asset. Jonathan's Landing delivers golf and boating in the same town for a fraction of the entry price. Neither is a substitute for the other, and most buyers know within one visit which one fits.

The useful overlap is narrow. A harbor home in Jonathan's Landing and a condominium or villa in Admirals Cove can cost about the same. That is the one budget where the two compete directly.

Admirals Cove and Jonathan's Landing, side by side
Two years of recorded closings, measured the same way
Admirals Cove
Jonathan's Landing
Median house price
$7.9M
$1.9M
Median house price per square foot
$1,543
$731
Closings at $1M and above
85
54
Median days to contract
38
16
Share of original asking price
92%
93%
Highest recorded sale
$34.5M
$7.5M
Median house size
4,549 sq ft
2,690 sq ft
Golf
45 holes
45 holes
Boating
Private marina, ocean access
Marina on the Intracoastal
Residences
About 900
About 1,200

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

What Each One Is

Admirals Cove is Jupiter's benchmark club. Interior waterways reach deep into the community, so a large share of its houses have private docks with ocean access. The club runs as a full resort, with its own marina.

Jonathan's Landing is older, larger and more relaxed. Its three courses and its marina serve about twelve hundred residences across many small neighborhoods. The culture is casual, and the range of homes is wide.

Four Times the Price, Twice the Rate per Foot

Houses in Admirals Cove sold for a median of $1,543 per square foot, against $731 in Jonathan's Landing. Much of that premium is the dock. Deep water behind the house, with ocean access, is the scarcest thing either community sells.

Admirals Cove also has a second market inside it. Thirty of its sales were condominiums and villas, at a median of $2.8M. They carry the same club at a much lower purchase price, and they cost more than the typical house in Jonathan's Landing.

The ceilings are far apart. Admirals Cove recorded twenty one sales at ten million dollars and above, including a club record of $34.5M in October. The highest sale in Jonathan's Landing was $7.5M, for a house on its harbor.

Two communities, two price ranges
Closings by price range at $1M and above, November 2024 through October 2026

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

The two markets by product
Houses and attached residences on separate lines
← Scroll to see all columns →
SegmentClosingsVolumeMedian$ / SqFtDays
Admirals Cove, houses55$553.9M$7.9M$1,54342
Admirals Cove, condos and townhouses30$91.4M$2.8M$1,15432
Jonathan's Landing, houses51$123.8M$1.9M$73117
Jonathan's Landing, condos and townhouses3$4.4M$1.6M$6372

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.

The largest sales in each community
The five largest recorded sales in each, two years
← Scroll to see all columns →
PropertyMarketClosedPriceSqFt$ / SqFt
176 Spyglass LaneAdmirals CoveOct 29$34.5M19,206$1,796
209 Commodore DriveAdmirals CoveNov 18$34M24,320$1,398
217 Commodore DriveAdmirals CoveApr 13$23M9,764$2,356
126 Spinnaker LaneAdmirals CoveJun 17$22.3M9,971$2,233
127 Spinnaker LaneAdmirals CoveMay 2$20.9M8,838$2,368
3527 Jonathans Harbour DriveJonathan's LandingJul 1$7.5M6,104$1,229
3164 Casseekey Island RoadJonathan's LandingSep 30$6.8M4,381$1,564
3551 Jonathans Harbour DriveJonathan's LandingAug 27$6.1M3,947$1,545
3330 Bridgegate DriveJonathan's LandingNov 1$4.3M4,360$986
3320 Bridgegate DriveJonathan's LandingJan 13$4.2M3,804$1,112

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

Both Sell Quickly, One Sells in Days

Both are liquid. The median Admirals Cove sale reached contract in 38 days. In Jonathan's Landing the median was 16 days, among the fastest of any club community this desk tracks.

Speed at that level changes how a buyer should prepare. A well priced house in Jonathan's Landing may be under contract before a second showing can be arranged. Buyers who have settled their membership questions in advance are the ones who win those houses.

Two years, one at a time
Each market in two twelve-month windows
← Scroll to see all columns →
SegmentClosingsVolumeMedian$ / SqFtDays
Admirals Cove, Nov 2024 to Oct 202547$337.1M$3.8M$1,24735
Admirals Cove, Nov 2025 to Oct 202638$308.3M$5.2M$1,38741
Jonathan's Landing, Nov 2024 to Oct 202526$56.9M$1.9M$73116
Jonathan's Landing, Nov 2025 to Oct 202628$71.3M$1.9M$73016

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.

Who Each One Suits

Admirals Cove suits the owner of a serious boat, and the buyer who wants a club that operates like a resort every day of the year. It asks for more capital and gives a deeper resale market at the top.

Jonathan's Landing suits the buyer who wants golf and the water without the scale. It is also the more forgiving place to start, because its prices leave room to renovate.

Membership works differently at each club, and the terms belong to the clubs. We walk buyers through both structures before any offer is written.

Bottom Line

Admirals Cove and Jonathan's Landing offer the same ingredients at very different scales. Admirals Cove costs about four times as much for the median house and holds every sale above ten million dollars. Jonathan's Landing sells faster than almost any club community in the county and opens the same Jupiter life at a lower price.

The working rule for Jupiter's marina clubs: size the boat and the budget first. The right gate follows from both.

Every figure is a BeachesMLS recorded closing at $1,000,000 or above from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. That is 85 sales in Admirals Cove and 54 in Jonathan's Landing. The scope is each club's own gates, as this site's community pages define them. One record is counted per sale, with listings entered twice matched on address and price. Medians are used throughout and print only at three sales or more. Days measure list date to contract. Transfers recorded only by deed are outside this count. Club membership terms come from each club directly and are not published here.

BeachesMLS recorded closings via our licensed feed, pulled November 16, 2026.

Nikko Karki
Written by

Nikko Karki

Nikko Karki has worked in real estate for nearly two decades, beginning on the developer side at Related Group in West Palm Beach, then through private real estate investments and cross-border M&A across the U.S., Europe, and Southeast Asia. He holds an M.Sc. in economics from the Helsinki School of Economics. He built Palm Beach Luxury to make his analysis available to anyone in the market, for free.
About our team →
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. The median house in Admirals Cove closed at $7.9M over two years, against $1.9M in Jonathan's Landing. Per square foot the figures were $1,543 and $731.
Yes. Admirals Cove has a private marina and many houses with their own docks and ocean access. Jonathan's Landing has a marina on the Intracoastal and harbor homes with dockage.
Jonathan's Landing. Its median sale reached contract in 16 days, against 38 days in Admirals Cove. Both are fast by the standard of private club communities.
Palm Beach Luxury

Every article we write is built on the same research we use to advise our clients. If anything here sparked your interest, we'd welcome a conversation.

Start a Conversation