The Bears Club or Old Palm?

Buyer Intelligence

The Bears Club or Old Palm?

Nikko Karki
Nikko Karki November 10, 2026
The Bears Club in Jupiter and Old Palm Golf Club in Palm Beach Gardens are ten minutes apart and often appear on the same buyer's list. Both are built around one golf course and estate lots. The similarity ends at the price. The median house at The Bears Club closed at $15.5M over the last two years, and the median at Old Palm at $5.2M. One is among the most expensive addresses in Florida. The other is the estate club more buyers can actually enter.
The Bears Club houses
$15.5M
Median of 11 house sales
Old Palm houses
$5.2M
Median of 37 house sales
The Bears Club per sq ft
$1,584
Median house, same window
Old Palm per sq ft
$1,138
Median house, same window

The Short Answer

The Bears Club is for the buyer who wants the largest house, the most privacy and Jack Nicklaus's own club, and who can wait for the right property. Old Palm is for the buyer who wants a serious golf club and an estate without the wait.

Membership decides more than price at both. The Bears Club is by invitation. Old Palm offers membership with ownership. A buyer should understand each club's process before touring a single house.

The Bears Club and Old Palm, side by side
Two years of recorded closings, measured the same way
The Bears Club
Old Palm
Median house price
$15.5M
$5.2M
Median house price per square foot
$1,584
$1,138
Closings at $1M and above
16
37
Median days to contract
96
54
Share of original asking price
88%
92%
Highest recorded sale
$48M
$14M
Median house size
10,160 sq ft
5,233 sq ft
Golf
Jack Nicklaus course
Raymond Floyd course
Membership
By invitation
Equity, with ownership
Sales at $10M and above
11
4

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

What Each One Is

The Bears Club is Jack Nicklaus's home club, with a small number of estate lots around his course. Houses are very large, and the club also holds a group of smaller club residences. Very few properties change hands in a year.

Old Palm has about three hundred homes around a Raymond Floyd course. It is known for open play with no tee times and for its practice facility. The houses range from golf cottages to custom estates.

The Bears Club Costs Three Times as Much

The median house at The Bears Club is nearly twice the size of the median at Old Palm, and it sold for $1,584 per square foot against $1,138. The buyer pays more for every foot and buys many more of them.

The Bears Club recorded eleven sales at ten million dollars and above, led by one at $48M. Old Palm recorded four, with a high of $14M. Most Old Palm sales fell between five and ten million dollars.

There is a lower rung at The Bears Club. Five of its sales were attached club residences, at a median of $5.3M. They cost about what an Old Palm estate does.

Old Palm trades in the middle, The Bears Club at the top
Closings by price range at $1M and above, November 2024 through October 2026

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

The two markets by product
Houses and attached residences on separate lines
← Scroll to see all columns →
SegmentClosingsVolumeMedian$ / SqFtDays
The Bears Club, houses11$244.8M$15.5M$1,58471
The Bears Club, condos and townhouses5$26.1M$5.3M$1,417108
Old Palm, houses37$223.9M$5.2M$1,13854

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.

The largest sales in each club
The five largest recorded sales in each, two years
← Scroll to see all columns →
PropertyMarketClosedPriceSqFt$ / SqFt
152 Bears Club DriveThe Bears ClubFeb 18$48M16,337$2,938
118 Bears Club DriveThe Bears ClubFeb 27$41M23,029$1,780
228 Bears Club DriveThe Bears ClubJul 15$33.8M10,896$3,099
136 Bears Club DriveThe Bears ClubMar 12$19.6M12,382$1,584
124 Bears Club DriveThe Bears ClubMar 20$18.5M10,160$1,821
12218 Tillinghast CircleOld PalmMar 31$14M9,805$1,428
11749 Belladonna CourtOld PalmJul 29$13.5M11,510$1,173
12210 Tillinghast CircleOld PalmJul 27$11.5M8,254$1,396
11612 Charisma WayOld PalmFeb 26$10.7M7,467$1,433
11769 Calla Lilly CourtOld PalmMar 13$8.7M7,392$1,177

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale.

Old Palm Is the Faster, Deeper Market

Old Palm recorded 37 sales in two years against 16 at The Bears Club. Its median sale reached contract in 54 days, and in the most recent year the pace roughly tripled. Sellers there kept 92 percent of their original asking prices.

The Bears Club runs on a longer clock. Its median sale took 96 days and closed at 88 percent of the first asking price. With so few sales, each one is negotiated on its own terms.

Two years, one at a time
Each market in two twelve-month windows
← Scroll to see all columns →
SegmentClosingsVolumeMedian$ / SqFtDays
The Bears Club, Nov 2024 to Oct 20258$120.4M$13.2M$1,434158
The Bears Club, Nov 2025 to Oct 20268$150.5M$16.2M$1,70062
Old Palm, Nov 2024 to Oct 202517$98.1M$5.2M$1,07392
Old Palm, Nov 2025 to Oct 202620$125.8M$5.3M$1,17532

BeachesMLS recorded closings, November 2024 through October 2026, one record per sale. Medians print at three sales or more.

Who Each One Suits

The Bears Club suits the buyer for whom the club itself is the reason to move. Patience and an introduction matter as much as budget.

Old Palm suits the buyer who wants to play every day, wants a newer estate and wants a market deep enough to sell into later. Its turnover makes pricing easier to read.

We do not publish either club's fees. Both clubs set their own terms, and we take buyers through them before an offer.

Bottom Line

The Bears Club and Old Palm are neighbors with different markets. The Bears Club sells a few very large estates a year at about three times Old Palm's median, on a slower clock and by invitation. Old Palm sells more than twice as many houses, faster and closer to their asking prices.

The working rule for the estate clubs: start with the membership conversation. The house search comes second.

Every figure is a BeachesMLS recorded closing at $1,000,000 or above from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. That is 16 sales in The Bears Club and 37 in Old Palm. The scope is each club's own gates, as this site's community pages define them. One record is counted per sale, with listings entered twice matched on address and price. Medians are used throughout and print only at three sales or more. Days measure list date to contract. Transfers recorded only by deed are outside this count. Club membership terms come from each club directly and are not published here.

BeachesMLS recorded closings via our licensed feed, pulled November 16, 2026.

Nikko Karki
Written by

Nikko Karki

Nikko Karki has worked in real estate for nearly two decades, beginning on the developer side at Related Group in West Palm Beach, then through private real estate investments and cross-border M&A across the U.S., Europe, and Southeast Asia. He holds an M.Sc. in economics from the Helsinki School of Economics. He built Palm Beach Luxury to make his analysis available to anyone in the market, for free.
About our team →
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, by about three times. The median house at The Bears Club closed at $15.5M over two years, against $5.2M at Old Palm.
Few. The Bears Club recorded 16 sales at $1M and above in two years, and Old Palm recorded 37.
The Bears Club is by invitation and publishes no terms. Old Palm offers equity membership with home ownership. Both clubs provide their terms directly.
Palm Beach Luxury

Every article we write is built on the same research we use to advise our clients. If anything here sparked your interest, we'd welcome a conversation.

Start a Conversation